Still as awesome as it was the first time I saw it. Doesn't lose it's appeal.







Last Edit: Feb 23, 2009 16:12:18 GMT by JD

The whole water idea is just awesome, very creative. Also like how the boards are spaced out, makes it looks neater. Not sure about the on/off buttons though, there are too many of those out there already.
Everything else looks good to me, now all you need is some content.

I love it!!!!!!!

I am thinking about joining , but anyways...I love the ocean design. Now , the content part of it all!

lovely. I would love to see something other than darkness the lower you get. the banner is so wonderfully light and well done, I just hate to have the rest of the background bland and dull.

otherwise, very nice!

Wow. I didn't think it would ever get coded. Amazing.

Firstly, NICE WORK! It's not everyday you see a unique design. The whole transparency adds to the water theme. And the colors match perfectly. The coding looks like it took a lot of time (and I can't code). Please however, don't clutter it up (I know that's a stupid thing to say), the minimalist look works with the water. Thanks for sharing your tallent!

Very well organized forum. It's well built and simple! It's a forum that is very well generated to catch peoples eye and sign up. lulz

It gets darker simply because that's what happens in the real sea/ocean...

Issues: Board Names, and Board Descriptions. Skin highlight colors don't mean much in the colors you used. And you aren't giving a unique feel, for us to join.

But other than that. It's perfect

Banner is a brushed over stock with a few filters, and the rest of the graphics are bland and cliche. Doesn't help that the concept is vastly unoriginal outside of ProBoards and that the forum is missing key components like a logo.

Superb coding, just as everything Dreg codes.

Emoticons are basically just animation copies of the typical stuff you see around dA, nothing unique.



2/5.

1 point for superb coding, 1 point for the effort and because I feel bad handing out a 1/5.

On a whole it's looking very incomplete on the design side. Very bland and boring.





Last Edit: Mar 11, 2009 1:17:16 GMT by Spektral

Holy moly, is that a Proboard? My god, it is.

I love how you made it, but I slightly agree with Alex. It is a little to plain. Why not add a little towards the bottom? But I have to admit. AMAZING!

If there was a 4.5/5, I'd give you it, but there isn't so I'll give you this:

"The secret to creativity is knowing how to hide your sources"

Hilarious.

I'll lower my rating now that I know that a lot of the creativeness on there isn't your work.

In light of the new evidence, I too, will have to lower my evaluation.

Despite the fact you actually told people that the water wasn't a stock, and the site was made from scratch, it would have been amazing had it been true.

It was too good to be true.

And, hide your sources better.